2016年2月10日星期三

暴動

【旺角暴力衝突】被捕者或控「參與暴亂罪」 最高可判囚10年 (23:48)

警方開記招回應旺角昨晚的暴力衝突,問及今次會否是繼「六七暴動」後,首次用「參與暴亂罪」檢控被捕人士,警務署長盧偉聰表示手上沒有資料,不知上次是何時使用。本報向警察公共關係科查詢,警方是否曾以此罪起訴人,至截稿前未獲回覆。

商台引述湯家驊表示,根據公安條例,如果有超過3人使用暴力行為,令公眾感到恐慌,就可構成參與暴動罪,最高可判監10年。他指,自公安條例在1970年修訂,納入參與暴動罪後,當局未引用過有關罪名檢控。

對於如何界定「暴亂」,盧表示「暴亂」一字只是警方內部用以描述情況,並無法律效力,又舉例指「騷亂」相對「冇咁暴力、危險」,包括與警方有推撞及佔馬路,但今次有放火和刑毀情況,更有人投擲磚頭,「掟中頭可以殺人」,因此屬「暴亂」。

問及從何證明示威者早有預謀和計劃,盧指有物資車接載物資到場給暴徒使用,故認為他們有可能有組織,會繼續搜證和調查,但指不涉及三合會成員。
(明報即時新聞)

我想指出湯家驊的講法不正確, 暴亂罪在1970年訂立後, 2013年修訂過, 不過沒有實質修改, 只把罰款的金額改作等級, 但有關罪名已多次提出檢控, 上訴案例也有多宗。旺角暴動如連同蓄意傷人罪一同檢控, 理應上高院審理。湯家驊說未引用過有關罪名檢控並非實況。

22 則留言:

  1. 標怕,可否upload一兩宗暴亂罪ge案例黎睇下,我想了解下相關罪行的量刑準則

    回覆刪除
    回覆
    1. 好易揾喎, 你自己試下。

      刪除
    2. Bill, I wonder all these people who asked you for references (and sometimes your analysis) are law school students who are just too lazy to do their own homework of searching and researching. You are right in asking them to search for themselves. Just a guess and an opinion, don't mean to offend general readers.
      BJ

      刪除
    3. I really don't know who they are. I don't mind exchanging views but do mind if I end up doing homework for them. Appeal judgments are easy to find.

      刪除
    4. The most recent case: http://www.hklii.hk/cgi-bin/sinodisp/eng/hk/cases/hkca/2001/1.html
      2000年喜靈洲戒毒所監獄暴動,上訴庭認為該宗暴動罪的starting point為6年,個別被告連同縱火罪好像合共10年左右。

      刪除
    5. Yes, the Mongkok rioters should be prepared to be jailed for not less than 6 years.

      刪除
    6. thx.但我只繫中學生黎ga炸,吾繫d咩law student😂

      刪除
    7. 咁就讀好啲書, 學好本事也學抗爭。

      刪除
  2. Just some food for thought for the naïve miserable souls in Hong Kong:
    Canada is a democracy. The Prime Minister (ignore the Royal Assent for our current purpose.)is elected by one-person-one-vote. There's an established mechanism for the "Three Powers" to check and balance each other. But when it comes to the suppression of violence in public, the approach is more than iron-fisted. Check out what the police did on the web regarding the G-20 summit a few years back in Toronto. Check out how an innocent Polish immigrant was tasered to death at a Vancouver airport. Find out about a recent trial concluded in a Toronto court where a cop was convicted of attempted murder (strange and curious indeed! because this cop fired a total of nine shots at a teenager just wielding a knife. And the cop's lawyer would definitely appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada). Cases like this one happened many times in Canada. You may be shocked to learn that the cops here are trained to shoot at bigger targets. So in this case, it's the torso, not the limbs. Moreover, they are trained to disable their assailant within the shortest span of time. So, the heart is their target for practice. So give it a second thought if you're planning to hold a brick protest somewhere in Canada. You probably don't stand a chance of being arrested and there's no need to pose bail because your thoracic cavity is already full of bullet holes.

    回覆刪除
    回覆
    1. 講加拿大無用,香港不是民主亦不是自主國家,相反今次事件是之前爭取民主問題的一個間接廷申,請Mr Anonymous and a naïve miserable soul.不要亂用民主國的家事例做比較.

      思想幼稚但又自以為清高的離地中產如想引用事例,應引用你們祖国中共下的事例:
      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FmICNrpUqxE&t=236

      刪除
    2. 你好有發表慾, 可惜沒有求知慾, 會越搞越無知。

      刪除
    3. 「你好有發表慾, 可惜沒有求知慾, 會越搞越無知。」r you talking about me?無知那裡?

      刪除
  3. 我看見的不是暴力,而是香港人擺脫奴性束縛後的反擊力

    回覆刪除
    回覆
    1. To: 匿名2016年2月10日 下午11:36
      看來你不是眼睛有事,而是腦袋有問題.
      這叫好:「立場先行,智商低能.」

      刪除
    2. 匿名生,這是暴力.問題是你接受和不接受咁解.面對現實對得到別人支持有好處

      刪除
  4. 事實證明,香港越暴越亂越好,因為啲離地中產根本無心同香港共患難,一有事就會博命嗌走、甚至真係走,咁就唔會阻住我地上位、洗牌。

    各位,對付老屎急嘅終極方法出現了!

    為左串魚蛋、雞蛋仔,我地都要暴佢個動!咁班老屎急同中產閪就會極速收皮!

    同我有咁亂搞咁亂!

    回覆刪除
    回覆
    1. You can also kill your parents to get his house and property.

      刪除
    2. I think he was only satirical and didn't mean what he said.

      刪除
    3. The sentiment of '唯恐天下不亂' may however have hit rather closer to home amongst our riotous friends than is strictly comforting...
      -Kolya

      刪除
    4. 「香港越暴越亂越好」<---似乎有人無意中講出689的心聲.香港越亂北京主子越有要他連任的理由

      刪除
  5. 看來什麼爭取本土,爭取民主的各路人馬氣數已盡,跑出來的廢物越來越蠢也越來越顛。醜態畢露,羣醜紛呈,時日無多了,快快派幾件垃圾出來自焚啦,反正你地裡面絕大部分都系生無可戀的廢物。讀書唔成,打工唔掂,行江湖怕死,行正行?中文唔得,英文唔掂,無膽無力,除了鬧事,一事無成。像這種abcd 的廢物,除了在網上講廢話還能做什麼呢。一句LSF就已經高潮了。不如自動獻身出來自焚,至少有人知道你個名。生不能造福社會,至少可以做點公益,為社會減少了一件廢物。

    回覆刪除